Deer Management: Better Control?

Dave Windle


The Scottish Government is taking forward some of the recommendations from the Deer Working Group as part of its work on Biodiversity. On 23/6/23, it issued the following news release.

Measures to protect biodiversity and prevent nature loss.

Land managers will be given more powers to help control Scotland's rapidly growing deer population after updated rules were introduced to Parliament this week. The changes to existing laws will make it easier to reduce unsustainable deer numbers in order to protect plant life and boost rewilding efforts.

The refreshed regulations will allow authorised land managers to:

Biodiversity Minister Lorna Slater said:

"These changes – recommended by the Deer Working Group – will allow deer to be managed in a way that is both beneficial to our environment and the rural economies that rely upon deer.

"Deer are an iconic species that is synonymous with rural Scotland but their numbers have reached densities that can have a devastating impact on our land due to trampling and overgrazing. This activity can prevent new trees from growing and damage existing woodland.

"The changes to rules on ammunition will also boost Scotland's venison sector. Lead is toxic to humans and its presence can spoil venison products. That's why we are now allowing land managers to use different types of ammunition. This will make more venison available to both foreign and domestic markets.

Mike Daniels, Vice-Convenor of Scottish Environment LINK Deer Group said:

"We strongly support the Scottish Government's proposals to improve the flexibility of deer management, based on the independent scrutiny of the Deer Working Group and its final recommendations.

"More than ever we need to make all of the tools available to Scotland's skilled and experienced deer managers to deliver the urgent changes required for nature and for all of us."

Peter Clark, Scotland Director of British Association for Shooting and Conservation said:

"BASC Scotland supports the decision to amend the minimum bullet weight because it will make non-lead ammunition more accessible. "Many stalkers are already required to use lead-free ammunition, be it through lease conditions or AGHE requirement, thus this would ensure that stalkers in these situations can continue to manage deer populations and supply venison into the food chain."


© Nigel Corby cc by-sa 2.0

Nick Kempe has published a critique on his blog, parkswatchscotland: Red Deer and the natural environment - what differences will the changes to the legislation make?

A point made by a number of people is that the failure to increase the season for hinds seems strange. If the objective is to reduce the overall size of the deer population in Scotland, then the number of hinds must be brought down. One stag can fertilise many hinds. It is the number of hinds that will govern the rate of population increase (and hopefully, decrease).

The John Muir Trust has published an informative leaflet entitled "Let's get clear on deer". I recommend that you get hold of a copy. Ideally, make sure that you see the film. A useful article is "Fact vs fiction" in the Spring issue of the JMT Journal, Issue 74.


 

NEMT Front Page | Previous Page | Volume Index Page | Next Page | Journal Index Page

Please let the webmaster know if there are problems with viewing these pages or with the links they contain.